Poll: Clip position
- timberweasel
- Member
- Posts: 35
- Joined: Fri Sep 21, 2012 7:33 pm
- Location: Canada, Earth
Right-side tip-up carry on every folding knife for me.
Tip-down just doesn't feel right. It generally tends to poke my hand. (One exception to this would be the Caly Jr.)
In a way this helps limit the knives I want to purchase. If they can't be changed to tip-up or aren't tip-up only, I move on to another model.
Tip-down just doesn't feel right. It generally tends to poke my hand. (One exception to this would be the Caly Jr.)
In a way this helps limit the knives I want to purchase. If they can't be changed to tip-up or aren't tip-up only, I move on to another model.
My favorite Spyderco knives include: Caly 3.5, Chaparral, Delica 4 FFG, Stretch, Para-Military 2, Endura 4 FFG, Manix 2 & Manix 2 XL!
TANSTAAFL
TANSTAAFL
It's funny, I almost didn't buy my first Military because it is a tip down.
Now I carry all of my knives that way, unless that option isn't available.
When I am in public, I ike the Yo2 loose in my front right as a SD knife,
I can walk thru parking lots etc with my hand in my pocket on the Yo.
It makes it inconspicuous, but I feel safer, JIC.
Now I carry all of my knives that way, unless that option isn't available.
When I am in public, I ike the Yo2 loose in my front right as a SD knife,
I can walk thru parking lots etc with my hand in my pocket on the Yo.
It makes it inconspicuous, but I feel safer, JIC.
Clipped, back right pocket or right side pocket if cargo pockets are available. Tip up or down, it doesn't matter. I do make most of my own lowrider clips, but I won't drill and tap additional holes. Not fussy about knives not having clips either, I carry my GB Air or Fallkniven U2 in their own pocket, usually cargo right.
Tip up whenever possible. I have a couple of knives that only do tip down so on the rare occassions that I carry those, I make do. I'm right-handed as well, so tip-up right was my vote.
"A flute with no holes is not a flute. A donut with no hole, is a danish."
Quietly lurking the Spyderco forum since 2003...
Quietly lurking the Spyderco forum since 2003...
I actually feel the exact opposite about drawing my knife. Tip up has always felt like less re-positioning in my hand was needed before deploying. :)DeathBySnooSnoo wrote:I am a fan of no clip...especially in a small knife. But as a lefty I obviously want lefthand carry and I like tip down. Because I pinch the pivot to draw the knife out and then it just swings down and I am holding the knife as I would. To me tip up is extra work...
"A flute with no holes is not a flute. A donut with no hole, is a danish."
Quietly lurking the Spyderco forum since 2003...
Quietly lurking the Spyderco forum since 2003...
-
- Member
- Posts: 3660
- Joined: Tue Jan 18, 2011 6:30 pm
- Location: Toronto Canada
I've just never understood how that is possible. I've tried it both ways and tip up leaves me holding the knife at the tail end, so I have to really reposition in order to be gripping it in a usable manner. But tip down, grab it by the pivot and it swings down into my hand and is in the exact position I need to open it, so I move my thumb off the pivot and onto the hole.ASmitty wrote:I actually feel the exact opposite about drawing my knife. Tip up has always felt like less re-positioning in my hand was needed before deploying. :)
On the hunt for...
I don't grab the knife only by the part that is sticking out at the top of my pocket. I make my draw by putting my thumb in my pocket on the side of the scale it needs to be so that the tail end of the knife is nestled in my palm. This way the knife is virtually in the in-hand position when I pull it out.DeathBySnooSnoo wrote:I've just never understood how that is possible. I've tried it both ways and tip up leaves me holding the knife at the tail end, so I have to really reposition in order to be gripping it in a usable manner. But tip down, grab it by the pivot and it swings down into my hand and is in the exact position I need to open it, so I move my thumb off the pivot and onto the hole.
"A flute with no holes is not a flute. A donut with no hole, is a danish."
Quietly lurking the Spyderco forum since 2003...
Quietly lurking the Spyderco forum since 2003...
I don't really fit into one category, it varies by knife for me but I am right handed. I find the military works well tip down, for keeping the larger blade in check and having your hand at the right end of that big handle to open the knife. A minor drawback of tip-down I find is having to rotate the knife into opening position, but it becomes a fluid movement you get used to.
What I usually carry is a Paramilitary 2 or similar sized knife, in tip UP position which I find most natural as the knife comes out facing the right way and can be opened without changing grip.
Smaller knives like the dodo, leafstorm, techno I prefer to carry loose in pocket maybe with a small lanyard.
The other way I use is clip left, tip up, with a wave. It's a configuration native to the p'kal and I also carry my delica this way. Works well for a second knife either top of the front pocket or rear pocket.
What I usually carry is a Paramilitary 2 or similar sized knife, in tip UP position which I find most natural as the knife comes out facing the right way and can be opened without changing grip.
Smaller knives like the dodo, leafstorm, techno I prefer to carry loose in pocket maybe with a small lanyard.
The other way I use is clip left, tip up, with a wave. It's a configuration native to the p'kal and I also carry my delica this way. Works well for a second knife either top of the front pocket or rear pocket.
I see, said the blind man.
Tip-up, with the pocket-clip on the side of the knife that is in my hand palm. It is not a carry preference, it is because for me the knife gives a better feel in hand with a pocket clip mounted like this. I don't like much the feel of the military with its one way mounted pocket-clip.
(N.B.: I don't like when the holes for the screws of the tip-down option let the washers exposed to dust).
(N.B.: I don't like when the holes for the screws of the tip-down option let the washers exposed to dust).
I checked two boxes (it appeared the poll allowed this). One was right side tip up, which is how I carry all clipped knives for ergonomic consistency. The other was no clip, which I also do. Clipless happens most often in dress pants with 3" bladed folders. Larger knives are a pain to extract from most pocket bottoms.
I don't fit any categories so I didn't cast a vote.
For small to medium models- doesn't matter. I've learned to deploy pocket knives either way with no issue for my purposes anyway.
For large models - prefer tip down. Just for grins and when no one is looking, I like to flick open the blade, but with my middle finger rather than thumb. Having the clip mounted for tip down carry facilitates this methods nicely. I've been doing this for a long time and developed the middle finger strength to flick even some of the stronger spring tensioned mid-locks like the Police and Ulize.
I like to carry RBP or IWB (1 or 5 O'clock).
For small to medium models- doesn't matter. I've learned to deploy pocket knives either way with no issue for my purposes anyway.
For large models - prefer tip down. Just for grins and when no one is looking, I like to flick open the blade, but with my middle finger rather than thumb. Having the clip mounted for tip down carry facilitates this methods nicely. I've been doing this for a long time and developed the middle finger strength to flick even some of the stronger spring tensioned mid-locks like the Police and Ulize.
I like to carry RBP or IWB (1 or 5 O'clock).
Tip up right.
Thanks,
jwh :spyder:
[CENTER]Manix 2 / Native Lightweight FRN / ParaMilitary 2 / Endura 4 FRN / Delica 4 FRN
UK Penknife FRN / Native 5 / Leafstorm / Urban Wharncliffe / Stretch FRN / ManBug G10 [/CENTER]
[CENTER]Delica 4 FRN / Dragonfly 2 H1 FRN / Yojimbo 2 / Ladybug 3 H1 FRN / Military [/CENTER]
jwh :spyder:
[CENTER]Manix 2 / Native Lightweight FRN / ParaMilitary 2 / Endura 4 FRN / Delica 4 FRN
UK Penknife FRN / Native 5 / Leafstorm / Urban Wharncliffe / Stretch FRN / ManBug G10 [/CENTER]
[CENTER]Delica 4 FRN / Dragonfly 2 H1 FRN / Yojimbo 2 / Ladybug 3 H1 FRN / Military [/CENTER]