Straight-Spined Stretch 2

rororo64 · #1

Hey all,
I was wondering if there is any new info on the proposed Straight-Spined Stretch 2 or if it is even going to happen. I like the regular Stretch 2 but not so much the blade shape on it and with a straight spine I think it would be a lot nicer. Also, what are your opinions on the possibility of a Straight-Spined Stretch 2? Would you like to see one or no, and if yes, what would you like to see on it?

Sequimite · #2

I did see one at OKCA and didn't care for it. It makes a distinct knife design look like another one just like the other one.

add: the straight spine becomes the only bold straight line on the knife. Looks fine on the Military or Para, not on the Stretch.

DeathBySnooSnoo · #3

I love the regular stretch, love the blade shape. I think that it is pretty close to perfect...so much so that I overlook the frn and carry it every day. And while I don't like the sound of a straight spined stretch...I will reserve final judgement until I see it.

jezabel · #4

I have no problems with the current Stretch's shape. I'm saying yes for the time being on a straight spine version, but really I'd pass judgement once I see or handle one.

J

The Mentaculous · #5

There's nothing I would change about the Stretch 2 to make it better, save maybe making the choil deeper, but that would probably entail more design changes that wouldn't be worth it. I say if you want a similar size and ergo'd knife with a straight spine, get a Para 2

Ben_1323 · #6

I would like one, but not as a replacement to the current Stretch. The drop point blade shape is what makes it unique, IMO. So make the straight-spine version a new model or an addition to the Stretch line.

chuck_roxas45 · #7

Yup, I wanna see it but that's not to say I'll buy it straight off. I decide when I see it. I kinda like the stretch's shape now.

avoidspam · #8

personally I'm all for a bit of variety. I like to current blade shape because it is so versatile. I use the stretch to skin and dress rabbits, I'm not sure a straight edged blade would perform this task as well. The narrow long shape of the current blade also enables you to make concave cuts more easily (an example i'm sure many of us will recognise is removing the core from a segment of apple (something that's quite difficult with a sage)). I also like the visual shape of the blade against the handle, particularly when closed. That being said I'd be curious to see a straight edged version as long as Spyderco carried on making the original (somehow i doubt they would).

Michael Cook · #9

:spyder: The stretch is a skinning knife. If it were straight like a d3 or e3 it would too easily mar the hide of whatever you're skinning. :spyder:

SolidState · #10

Sequimite wrote:I did see one at OKCA and didn't care for it. It makes a distinct knife design look like another one just like the other one.

add: the straight spine becomes the only bold straight line on the knife. Looks fine on the Military or Para, not on the Stretch.

I also handled this knife at the OKCA and wondered why people didn't buy a FFG endura if that's what they want. It basically becomes an Endura with a different handle at that point.

The Deacon · #11

Assuming it's being done as an addition to the lineup, rather than as a replacement for the drop point version, I'm all for it. I've grown to appreciate the Stretch's drop point blade, and would hate to see it disappear. However, I know that it has kept some from purchasing one, so adding a straight spine version would increase the number of potential buyers. Regardless of blade shape, the Stretch is a totally different knife from the Endura. Its 50/50 choil and structured handle give it completely different, and to me infinitely superior, ergonomics.

TCRooster · #12

I agree 100% with The Deacon. Make it in addition to, not as a replacement for, the drop point Stretch 2. As long as that is the case, go for it. If it is a replacement, I hope they don't do it. The Stretch is so wonderful as-is, but I wouldn't hesitate to add a straight spined version if one became available!

araneae · #13

The Mentaculous wrote:There's nothing I would change about the Stretch 2 to make it better, save maybe making the choil deeper, but that would probably entail more design changes that wouldn't be worth it.

I feel the same, but would reserve judgement until I see one.

jackknifeh · #14

I'd say leave it the way it is. Another model with a straight spine would be ok as long as the existing model blade stays. I saw a post where someone said the blade shape made it easier to clean game because of a narrower blade. I don't benefit from the existing blade except for less weight but others seem to. I'm sure a straight spine Stretch would be nice but I like the one I have and wouldn't get one because of a different spine. Just me though.

Jack

JoePepper · #15

I really hope they don't change a thing on the stretch.

unit · #16

I would like to hear why anyone wants it straight. Specifically, how will a straight spine improve performance over the current shape.

bh49 · #17

I like an idea of straight-spined stretch, but cannot comment, until I see the picture

Donut · #18

I want to see it, I might get one. I wonder if we can get this one with a thinner blade stock. :D

jackknifeh · #19

unit wrote:I would like to hear why anyone wants it straight. Specifically, how will a straight spine improve performance over the current shape.

I know someone who handled my knives and hated the look of the Stretch blade spine. Just appearance, nothing to do with performance but it would have kept him from getting one. I think his mind is changing a little with time, but that's the only time I heard someone say anything bad about the blade. He didn't say it was bad, just not his cup of tea.

My opinion is a straight would improve only in strength (if any). If that is what you need, then Endura 4. If you need a knife where cutting curves is done a lot the narrow blade would be beneficial for turning radius. Think of cutting wood with a jig-saw using "normal" blades and the narrower coping blades if you want to make radical cutting curves as an example.

Other than any performance issues I prefer the Stretch because of the handle and that's all.

Jack

Jazz · #20

I really need to see it first... we need to keep the old Stretch how it is, and adding a new design would be okay (have both offered). It's perfect how it is. I do like the straight spine design like the Delica, etc. and this would be a nice mid sized offering of it, with a most excellent handle shape. At first I was disgusted at the thought, but I've thought a bit about it. I say yes, but definately keep the original in the lineup, or no.

- best wishes, Jazz.

Spyderco Forums

Straight-Spined Stretch 2

Would you like to see a Straight-Spined Stretch 2?

Straight-Spined Stretch 2