Sage vs Manix, Native & Caly3

Discuss Spyderco's products and history.
flash900
Member
Posts: 464
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 3:23 pm
Location: Midwest

#21

Post by flash900 »

SteelDragon wrote:If you keep posting good reviews like this then yes the price will likely go up cause now you have me wanting one also :)
In that case, I never liked the Sage.
Now will the price go down?
Spydies: Caly 3 & Jr.; Michael Walker; Dragonfly, 2 & G10; Delica 4, FFG, G10, & Wave; Endura G10 & Wave; Rookie; Ambitious, Persistence, Tenacious; Sage 1, 2, 3; CAT CF & G10; Chicago CF; Ladybug; Bradley; Manix 2, Blue & XL; Native 4, 5 & Forum; Balance; Rescue; Salt I & Pacific; D'Allara; Junior; PPT; SuperLeaf; Urban Safety Orange; Para 2; Matriarch 2 & Lil'; Techno; Southard; Tuffthumbz Sage 2 & Para 2 mods; Cuscadi Pingo; Domino; Slysz Bowie
bdbender
Member
Posts: 75
Joined: Fri Oct 23, 2009 11:16 am
Location: Santa Fe, NM

#22

Post by bdbender »

Whatever sort of fierce appliance the Manix is, I agree that it is in a different class than the others.

I carried a Native for a while, loved the ergonomics, but didn't like the thick blade. My wife now has it. Looking forward to the FFG Native 4.

I carried a Sage CF for a while, a terrific knife, flawless build quality, my favorite lock ever, great textured handle. But it was just a little too bulky for my work clothes (I work in an office): it would never "disappear", I always knew it was there. Also, I prefer a blade profile a little more pointed and corresponding handle profile a little thinner, and the Sage blade is pretty fat.

I carried a Caly3 CF for a while, terrific ergonomics and did I mention my preference for the wire clip? This is the most gentlemanly of the bunch, but for that use I really prefer the Walker CF.

On a whim, I bought a G10 UKPK, which has the same form as the Caly3, and is quite a bit lighter. This is what I carry now - I really like the slipit much better than I thought I would, after years of carrying lockers - and the lighter weight is a plus, too.

The type of steel has not really been an issue in this thread, but I have come to prefer S30V to ZDP-189 for EDC, although it would be hard to explain why. Just sort of feels better. So I guess that's a vote for the Sage.
ABX2011
Member
Posts: 2316
Joined: Thu Oct 01, 2009 7:54 pm

#23

Post by ABX2011 »

The Sage I was cheap for a period when there was some kind of special offered by a distributor. So I wouldn't expect the price to go back down.
flash900
Member
Posts: 464
Joined: Sun Jan 10, 2010 3:23 pm
Location: Midwest

#24

Post by flash900 »

ABX2011 wrote:The Sage I was cheap for a period when there was some kind of special offered by a distributor. So I wouldn't expect the price to go back down.
Aha. Pity. Thanks.
Spydies: Caly 3 & Jr.; Michael Walker; Dragonfly, 2 & G10; Delica 4, FFG, G10, & Wave; Endura G10 & Wave; Rookie; Ambitious, Persistence, Tenacious; Sage 1, 2, 3; CAT CF & G10; Chicago CF; Ladybug; Bradley; Manix 2, Blue & XL; Native 4, 5 & Forum; Balance; Rescue; Salt I & Pacific; D'Allara; Junior; PPT; SuperLeaf; Urban Safety Orange; Para 2; Matriarch 2 & Lil'; Techno; Southard; Tuffthumbz Sage 2 & Para 2 mods; Cuscadi Pingo; Domino; Slysz Bowie
Post Reply