Spyderco or Columbia River?
Spyderco or Columbia River?
Howdy folks - Obviously there are a lot of devoted fans of Spyderco knives here. I have heard nothing but good things about them to date myself. I am considering however, buying a Columbia River M16 or a Crawford/Kasper folder for a strong, heavy duty daily use knive as well as a defensive tool. Does anyone here have any experience with either of these two CRKT knives? I am interested in a comparison with a similar Spyderco product. Thanks for any help you can offer. Jeff/1911.
-
shootist16
- Member
- Posts: 337
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:33 am
- Location: Knoxville, Tennessee USA
-
cuttingstick
- Member
- Posts: 1
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:33 am
The biggest thing I have noticed about the CRKT KFF is the AUS 6 steel isn't the greatest stuff in the world. It's pretty soft and won't hold an edge nearly as long as some of the other steels out there. There are Spydies in a similar size range that would work tons better IMHO. The price will probably be a bit higher though.
-
nsfirechap
- Member
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:33 am
Jeff, Aus6 and Aus8 are NOT in the near of most of the high end quality steels.
Aus6 is similar to 440A and Aus8 to 440B AFAIK. They are not bad steels, however they can not be compared to steels like; VG-10, CPM 440V, ATS-34 and ATS-55.
So, there is your answer. Most of the Spydies will feature better a steel (IMHO)than the one in your CRKT knife.
Than again, it depends on for what purpose you will use the knife. If it were to be a knife used in humid conditions than it would be fully correct (high corrosion resistance and toughness)!
Have a knife´s day <img src="smile.gif" width=15 height=15 align=middle>
Aus6 is similar to 440A and Aus8 to 440B AFAIK. They are not bad steels, however they can not be compared to steels like; VG-10, CPM 440V, ATS-34 and ATS-55.
So, there is your answer. Most of the Spydies will feature better a steel (IMHO)than the one in your CRKT knife.
Than again, it depends on for what purpose you will use the knife. If it were to be a knife used in humid conditions than it would be fully correct (high corrosion resistance and toughness)!
Have a knife´s day <img src="smile.gif" width=15 height=15 align=middle>
I just bought a Columbia River M-16-04 (large, tanto style, plain edge). I simply couldn't resist. I really like the flipper and that big, chunky blade.
Anyway, now I'm trying to decide which Spyderco to buy to go with it, for a slightly more compact carry...maybe every other day, or something like that. ****, I'll probably carry them both.
I like the Delica, but I can't see myself buying one when the Endura is only a few dollars more, for a larger knife.
Next, I really like the looks and heft of the stainless models but it would appear that the S/S Endura is only available in AUS-6 steel, and either full plain or full serrated style, whereas the lightweight version is made with ATS-55 and is also available with a 50/50 blade.
Sal, if you're listening...why is this?
Jeff/1911.
Anyway, now I'm trying to decide which Spyderco to buy to go with it, for a slightly more compact carry...maybe every other day, or something like that. ****, I'll probably carry them both.
I like the Delica, but I can't see myself buying one when the Endura is only a few dollars more, for a larger knife.
Next, I really like the looks and heft of the stainless models but it would appear that the S/S Endura is only available in AUS-6 steel, and either full plain or full serrated style, whereas the lightweight version is made with ATS-55 and is also available with a 50/50 blade.
Sal, if you're listening...why is this?
Jeff/1911.
