List your 10 most Favorite Production Fixed Blade Knives for SD

If your topic has nothing to do with Spyderco, you can post it here.
JD Spydo
Member
Posts: 23725
Joined: Tue Sep 28, 2004 7:53 pm
Location: Blue Springs, Missouri

The Doctor sure ordered this thread

#21

Post by JD Spydo »

I am finding this thread extremely awesome. Because to be painfully/truthfully honest with you guys I've always admired fixed blades but I haven't devoted myself to them nearly as much as I've wanted to in the past. I feel like I've just scratched the surface and I'm darn glad the good Doctor felt compelled to put this thread up.

First of all I want all of the Spyderco big boys that I don't currently have i.e. the Rock Salt, Temperance 2 and more of the Temp 1s if I can find them and particularly the Spyderedged versions. The Spyderco Warrior literally has me thinking about taking on 3 jobs just so I can get one quick.

Some of the other stuff you guys have mentioned like the Szabo line and those magnificent Fallkniven blades have always garnered my utmost respect. My most wanted Bowie is without a doubt the Fallkniven THOR model. That is a production masterpiece that any knife company should envy.

Now for roughhousing and just rambling through the timber I find some of my older Cold STeel stuff to be quite nice in a way. I particularly am fond of both the Gurkha Kukris I still have and use.

Great Thread Doc>> Great to see you back again too Sir :)
Long Live the SPYDEREDGE Spyderco Hawkbills RULE!!
User avatar
buglerbilly
Member
Posts: 732
Joined: Sat Apr 19, 2008 7:36 pm
Location: Perth, Western Australia

#22

Post by buglerbilly »

224477 wrote:Brian, the golok looks more like a shortened naginata to me. Traditional goloks do look a bit different.
Yeah I agree but I couldn't remember the name, not usually my area of interest............... ;)

BRIAN
User avatar
Dr. Snubnose
Member
Posts: 8799
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2005 9:54 pm
Location: NewYork

#23

Post by Dr. Snubnose »

JD Spydo wrote:I am finding this thread extremely awesome. Because to be painfully/truthfully honest with you guys I've always admired fixed blades but I haven't devoted myself to them nearly as much as I've wanted to in the past. I feel like I've just scratched the surface and I'm darn glad the good Doctor felt compelled to put this thread up.

First of all I want all of the Spyderco big boys that I don't currently have i.e. the Rock Salt, Temperance 2 and more of the Temp 1s if I can find them and particularly the Spyderedged versions. The Spyderco Warrior literally has me thinking about taking on 3 jobs just so I can get one quick.

Some of the other stuff you guys have mentioned like the Szabo line and those magnificent Fallkniven blades have always garnered my utmost respect. My most wanted Bowie is without a doubt the Fallkniven THOR model. That is a production masterpiece that any knife company should envy.

Now for roughhousing and just rambling through the timber I find some of my older Cold STeel stuff to be quite nice in a way. I particularly am fond of both the Gurkha Kukris I still have and use.

Great Thread Doc>> Great to see you back again too Sir :)
Thanks JD, I do hope you add some more great fixed blades to your collection knifebro....Doc :D
"Always Judge a man by the way he treats someone who could be of no possible use to him"

*Custom Avatar with the Help of Daywalker*
Dr. Detroit
Member
Posts: 28
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:33 am
Location: Michigan USA

#24

Post by Dr. Detroit »

I like the Spyderco Ronin, the REKAT Pikuni, and the Ontario Bagwell Fortress for SD.
The difference betwwen genius and stupidity is genius has it's limits
Jordan
Member
Posts: 1181
Joined: Tue Oct 18, 2005 8:56 pm
Location: Austin, TX

#25

Post by Jordan »

Alright... not sure if I can do 10, but I'll give it a shot.

1) Gerber Mk II. No question, my absolute favorite FA style blade... at least until Sal makes one :-D

2) KA BAR. Obligatory.

3) REKAT Hobbit Warrior

4) Spyderco Warrior. Per 3 and 4, what can I say... I am a sucker for those curves. Still putting pennies away for 4, but my REKAT is a prized part of my collection.

5) Cold Steel Khukri. If we are talking SD with any knife, regardless of the ability to conceal it in order to not start a panic wherever you go... I will always opt for the larger blades. The Khukri design in general is great for maximizing the impact of what is already an absurdly large piece of steel. Even a glancing blow with the forward curve of the blade can inflict massive damage, and a properly placed cut or stab will ignore heavy clothing and put steel to bone without issue. The model I own is the Ghurka Khukri... say what you will about Cold Steel... they know their way around a big knife. Which brings me to...

6) Cold Steel Laredo Bowie. Same argument as before per big blades... if I am not restricted by concealment requirements, I'm opting for the biggest hunk of high carbon I can find. My Laredo is a factory second (only way I could afford the **** thing), due to imperfections in the finish. Still, I like it and carry it fairly often when I'm outdoors.

7) Emerson Kerambit. Don't own one... I'm probably stretching to get 10 knives on the list. But, I sure would like one. I've no training in silat or anything like that, so it's unlikely that I could take full advantage of a kerambit. But, a wicked hawkbill is a wicked hawkbill... and I can see it coming in handy for SD.

8) Fairbairn Sykes Combat Dagger/ Fairbairn Applegate Dagger. To be perfectly honest, I'd prefer the Gerber Mk II to either. But, if you have to conceal a knife that packs the maximum punch... these will do the trick. As a matter of fact, seeing as they are both engineered to be the perfect fighting knife by some of the worlds foremost experts in hand to hand combat (circa WWI-II, anyway)... they will do better than the trick :-D

9) Boker Smatchet. Another Fairbairn design... and another one I don't own but, really, really want. Of course, my big knife preference and the limitations thereof still apply.

10) Um... Fremen Crysknife. Because the spice is life :-P. Only kidding, lets say... the Fallkniven A1. Cause it's pretty much the only other FB fighting knife that I can think of right now :-D.
Don't hit at all if it is honorably possible to avoid hitting; but never hit soft.
- Theodore Roosevelt

"I twisted the knife until I heard his heart-strings sing."

- Jim Bowie concerning Maj. Norris Wright
User avatar
Dr. Snubnose
Member
Posts: 8799
Joined: Sat Mar 05, 2005 9:54 pm
Location: NewYork

#26

Post by Dr. Snubnose »

Jordan wrote:Alright... not sure if I can do 10, but I'll give it a shot.

1) Gerber Mk II. No question, my absolute favorite FA style blade... at least until Sal makes one :-D

2) KA BAR. Obligatory.

3) REKAT Hobbit Warrior

4) Spyderco Warrior. Per 3 and 4, what can I say... I am a sucker for those curves. Still putting pennies away for 4, but my REKAT is a prized part of my collection.

5) Cold Steel Khukri. If we are talking SD with any knife, regardless of the ability to conceal it in order to not start a panic wherever you go... I will always opt for the larger blades. The Khukri design in general is great for maximizing the impact of what is already an absurdly large piece of steel. Even a glancing blow with the forward curve of the blade can inflict massive damage, and a properly placed cut or stab will ignore heavy clothing and put steel to bone without issue. The model I own is the Ghurka Khukri... say what you will about Cold Steel... they know their way around a big knife. Which brings me to...

6) Cold Steel Laredo Bowie. Same argument as before per big blades... if I am not restricted by concealment requirements, I'm opting for the biggest hunk of high carbon I can find. My Laredo is a factory second (only way I could afford the **** thing), due to imperfections in the finish. Still, I like it and carry it fairly often when I'm outdoors.

7) Emerson Kerambit. Don't own one... I'm probably stretching to get 10 knives on the list. But, I sure would like one. I've no training in silat or anything like that, so it's unlikely that I could take full advantage of a kerambit. But, a wicked hawkbill is a wicked hawkbill... and I can see it coming in handy for SD.

8) Fairbairn Sykes Combat Dagger/ Fairbairn Applegate Dagger. To be perfectly honest, I'd prefer the Gerber Mk II to either. But, if you have to conceal a knife that packs the maximum punch... these will do the trick. As a matter of fact, seeing as they are both engineered to be the perfect fighting knife by some of the worlds foremost experts in hand to hand combat (circa WWI-II, anyway)... they will do better than the trick :-D

9) Boker Smatchet. Another Fairbairn design... and another one I don't own but, really, really want. Of course, my big knife preference and the limitations thereof still apply.

10) Um... Fremen Crysknife. Because the spice is life :-P. Only kidding, lets say... the Fallkniven A1. Cause it's pretty much the only other FB fighting knife that I can think of right now :-D.
Good Choices Jordan, I'm not restricted on blade length either...hence the Rock Salt or Hissatsu on the right hip...I like a big blade....as far as Cold Steel IMHO they can't make a folder for the love of money but when it comes to fixed blades they get a nod from me in my book. The Smatchet (I got one) Gifted to me from Chad Los Banos (Daywalker) it is awesome if you like to wield a larger blade...Boker did a great job on them....Doc :)
"Always Judge a man by the way he treats someone who could be of no possible use to him"

*Custom Avatar with the Help of Daywalker*
User avatar
El Tigre
Member
Posts: 338
Joined: Thu Mar 13, 2008 3:47 am
Location: Argentina

#27

Post by El Tigre »

In no order:

_ Cold Steel black bear classic
_ Cold Steel Tai Pan
_ Benchmade Snody resistor
_ Spyderco Ronin
_ Boker Rampage
_ Blackhawk Kalista
_ KA.BAR TDI
_ Benchmade Snody Instigator
_ Spyderco Street Beat
_ Spyderco Swick

"El Tigre"
Folding knives can be classified in two large groups: Spydercos and the rest!

Please be patient, I dont speak english properly.
User avatar
skatenut
Member
Posts: 707
Joined: Thu Apr 02, 2009 12:21 pm
Location: Germany

#28

Post by skatenut »

not being trained in SD, I imagine these blades might be suitable, in no praticular order:

Spyderco Rock Salt
Spyderco Aqua Salt
Spyderco Ronin
Spyderco Street Beat
Spyderco Swick
Gerber Mark I (I always admired that non-slip handle)
Gerber Mark II
Cold Steel Tantos in various blade lengths
CRKT Bear Claw
Perrin and Emerson La Griffe
Post Reply