Thumb ramp or naw?

[TheGiant80]

Spyderco fans have their preferences. A real straight forward question that everyone’s got an opinion on; do you dig thumb ramps or not?

[Wartstein]

Spyderco fans have their preferences. A real straight forward question that everyone’s got an opinion on; do you dig thumb ramps or not?

Well.. no, not really
For me the option "don´t really care" is missing in your poll

Some thoughts though:

- I rarely use thumb ramps as such, but rather put my thumb on the side/flat of the blade, not the ramp - here the "ramp" can be advantageous, cause it makes for more surface on the flat to put the thumb on

- IF Is used thumb ramps as such: I think I´d prefer them to be not steep and rather subtle, perhaps even just a flat spine (so no ramp). As a matter of fact I put my thumb more often on the spine of folders that don´t have a ramp.

- I don´t mind at all that the ramp makes the knife wider in pocket. Width in pocket has never been a concern of mine, rather length and shape of the handle end (the Manix 2 LW is a great carry for me for example)

- I like that the ramp normally makes for an easier one handed opening (hole better accessible, better "arc of motion" for the thumb)

- I could also imagine that the taller blade the ramp creates could make for a bit better cutting geometry.

[Evil D]

Strongly prefer naw. I like it on some models but I often feel cramped when using them, and I find that I end up placing my thumb above them anyway. I think carrying a Yojimbo 2 for so long broke my love of thumb ramps.

[Jesla]

Not a Walmart shopper…. But I agree with Walmart, for this one. Shrink the hump…. Never happen though.

[JRinFL]

For me it depends on the knife. It certainly is not a binary decision. As a culture, we really need to stop making everything an either/or proposition.

[Tristan_david2001]

I dig them. But I certainly don’t hate the design of other knives that don’t have them and call them a naw. But generally I find all my favorite spyderco designs do have a ramped thumb rest. I generally find on a pocket knife, a curve that contours up on my thumb gives a nice solid pitch style of grip which feels like I have precise control over the blade.

[Mushroom]

For me it depends on the knife. It certainly is not a binary decision. As a culture, we really need to stop making everything an either/or proposition.

I couldnt agree more. Its like a form of dichotomous thinking that causes people to treat everything like a competition.

I’m indifferent towards thumb ramps. I like them on knives them have them and I like knives that dont have them.

[TheGiant80]

For me it depends on the knife. It certainly is not a binary decision. As a culture, we really need to stop making everything an either/or proposition.

Just a dumb poll I posted last night when I couldn’t sleep. Don’t think too deeply on it.

[Bill1170]

For me it depends on the knife. It certainly is not a binary decision. As a culture, we really need to stop making everything an either/or proposition.

Hard agree. Without context, thumb ramp or not is an incomplete query.

[TkoK83Spy]

I guess I don't mind a thumb ramp, but my favorite models tend to have a subtle or no ramp at all (Manix, Shaman, Native Chief) Though the UKPK is also up there on my list and has a pretty defined ramp. Probably depends on the day!

[Tristan_david2001]

While I understand what some are saying I think we can read between the lines and understand this thread was just meant to harmlessly start a discussion on whether some prefer they’re knives with a ramp or not and why, if you have no preference then that’s just fine also.

[Evil D]

While I understand what some are saying I think we can read between the lines and understand this thread was just meant to harmlessly start a discussion on whether some prefer they’re knives with a ramp or not and why, if you have no preference then that’s just fine also.

Yeah, kinda odd that this is being taken so concrete and literal and being seen in any way as a bad thing. If having a hard preference for something is bad then I think we're all guilty for preferring thumb holes and pocket clips and steel varieties and the list goes on. Some people absolutely won't buy non stainless steels, some refuse to buy coated blades, I thought this was the root purpose of a discussion forum.

[Coastal]

It's an interesting question because it made me think a little more about my preferences. That said, like others I don't really have a hard yes or no, so I was unable to vote.

First, the lack of a thumb ramp never bothers me. I would never decide not to buy a knife because there was no thumb ramp. On the other hand, I usually like a shallow ramp a little better. The best example is the Manix 2, which is well-nigh perfect for me.

An abrupt ramp is gradually becoming a hard no for me. It hasn't stopped me from buying several Mule Teams, but that ramp is borderline annoying, and I'm constantly on the verge of freehand modding one to see if I can improve it. I will eventually sell my Saver Salt because of the ramp. I recently returned an Atlantic Salt because I couldn't stand the ramp.

A steep ramp in the context of a reasonably friendly handle, a la the Pacific Salt or PM2, is okay, but shallower would feel even better. On a cramped or strongly finger-grooved handle, a steep ramp is a non-starter. I understand the purpose of the large Spydiehole, but I like the small hole better. I'll go as far as to say I'd prefer the small hole for all of Spyderco's knives, except those specifically aimed at the rescue use case, because of how it would improve the feel of the ramp.

[billdoier72]

Yes I do.

But I wouldn't want every knife to have one.

[SG89]

Gonna be a naw for me dawg

[JRinFL]

For me it depends on the knife. It certainly is not a binary decision. As a culture, we really need to stop making everything an either/or proposition.

Just a dumb poll I posted last night when I couldn’t sleep. Don’t think too deeply on it.

Sorry, it was not meant as an attack on you. It’s just something that’s been bothering me for awhile, though I should have left the last comment off of my reply.

[Foehammer]

It’s not something that I’ve ever considered when purchasing a knife. That being said I do think I prefer having them over not having them.

[mongo1958]

Spyderco fans have their preferences. A real straight forward question that everyone’s got an opinion on; do you dig thumb ramps or not?

In deed I do. But, I also like the other blades that do not sport the thumb ramp.
Case in point my Shaman, and Native 5.
Can You Dig it!!!

[JoviAl]

I like knives both ways I love a PM2 tanto but I also love a Yojumbo. I was recently considering BRK’s and I was surprised how polarising their thumb ramps seem to be in reviews.

[vandelay]

I prefer the half hump on knives like the Manix. It gives you some variation on where you put your thumb while still letting you put force into the knife with your thumb. The full hump also tends to create a but of a snag point.