short version:
Delica 4 saber grind. I thought the opening hole was great, and the edge retention was excellent. However, I disliked the flat saber grinds poor cutting ability, the clip and the ergonomics. Tried again with an
S60V Military. Loved it. Ergonomics were great, and how light it was really won me over.
They made me realize that many aspects of knife design had advanced a lot since the Victorinox Classic + Buck 110 combo I grew up with. It'd take me a while yet to appreciate clips though.
Long version:
Started knife collecting with a Victorinox Classic. As I grew up I tended to EDC one with a Buck 110...
I was content with that combo for quite a while.
Around 2005 I came across an awesome knife selection at a locally owned camping store. Everything from Smith and Wesson to Spyderco, Cold Steel to Benchmade, Ruko to customs.
First purchase was an Ontaro SP05. I always wanted a Kabar but this was styled similar to one at half the price. Tried to make it more suitable for bushcraft by thinning the edge, cutting off the top guard and dulling the sharpened clip point.
This was followed by my first name brand full sized modern folder, a CRKT Kit Carson flipper liner lock. Aluminum handles, G10 inserts, and AUS8 steel I believe.
It wasn't a bad knife by any means, but it never grew on me that much. I tried carrying it, but went back to my Buck 110's after a bit.
For a while I stopped there. The Ontario was fun to mess around with in the woods, and I figured the 110 was the folder for me.
Some time later I'm back in the camping store checking out the latest in LED flashlights for camping.
I see a Benchmade display and I'm blown away by the absurd prices. $200 pocket knives? Why?
Handled a full sized Skirmish and a Mini Skirmish. Was instantly blown away at how much higher quality they felt than my CRKT.
Instead of impulse buying a knife 8x more expensive than my EDC, I went home and did some research. I looked up how Spyderco actually came up with that opening hole idea, and decided to go with them instead of Benchmade.
I came across this forum and Bladeforums, and asked for advice on which models to consider.
Everyone said Delica 4, so I bought one without even holding it first. I still remember the clerk asking if I wanted to check it out, and I said no, don't bother, everyone says this is the best Spyderco to start out with.
So, here it is, my very first Spyderco from around 2006:
You'll notice I took the clip off. I wasn't a fan of how pocket clips felt at all when using the Delica, so I removed it. Pocket carry worked just fine with such a small model anyways.
You'll also see the blade is scratched from thinning it out flat to the saber grind with sandpaper.
I thought the cutting performance was really bad. While I appreciated the hardness and edge retention of VG10 VS Victorinox folders and Buck 110's, the saber ground blade was thick. It did a lot worse on apples, cardboard, wood carving etc.
Another issue was the size and ergonomics. I grew up using my Buck 110 with my thumb on the spine because that's how other people used theirs. The thumb ramp didn't give me enough space for my thumb.
So my first Spyderco was a real mixed bag. I thought it was well made, the build quality was very nice. The steel had the best edge retention of anything I had tried. I liked the opening hole a lot better than nail nicks or thumb studs. I liked how grippy the scales were, and how light the knife was. But the cutting performance was pretty bad on thicker materials, and the ergonomics left a lot to be desired for my grip, and I wasn't into the pocket clips.
I saw promise in the brand, I just needed to find the right model.
So I asked for suggestions again. "What Spyderco should I try if I think the Delica is too small and cuts poorly?"
"Military"
Why didn't people suggest this the first time, since I EDC'd a Buck 110? Oh well.
So I bought an S60V single liner Military. Here it is, my second Spyderco:
This was more like it. Much better fit for my hand. Much better cutting ability. Though you'll still see I tried thinning out the edge......much tougher to do than with 420HC or VG10.
I was really impressed with this knife. This is the one that made me get it. The size to weight ratio, coming from an old school Buck 110, really was something. Those single liner Military folders were even lighter than the current versions.
The ergonomics were, and still are, a perfect fit for my hand. I've kept a Millie or two in the collection since, even though I've always liked lockbacks better than liner locks.
The cutting ability was much higher than the Delicas too. Both edge retention and edge geometry were much better. I can remember carrying this to an overnight warehouse job, and breaking down a box with it. A box I didn't realize was reinforced with thin steel rods. I sliced right into it with this Military and there was no edge damage, it was still sharp. Really impressed me.
This was an old EDC of mine. That S60V Military, with the clip removed naturally. Along with my favorite keychain multitool, a Leatherman Micra. Keys to a late 90's stick shift Accord. And an old school LED light that had one mode, probably around 40 lumens or so.
Well, down the rabbit hole I went. From there I got a $115 C95 Manix, $25 Byrd Cara Cara, $40 Walmart Native, $75 ZDP189 Endura saber ground, $125 Police 3 as soon as it came out (I remember drooling over the amsterdam meet pics, still got it saved to my PC), Spin first run....then about 60 other models haha.
EDIT: Found the amsterdam meet photo of the Police 3
