Page 1 of 1

D2 steel question

Posted: Sun Mar 05, 2017 5:47 pm
by bryan123
Hi,

I have one new knife that had D2 steel, an Esee Zancudo. D2 is not quite stainless so I'd like to know what should be done to help prevent corrosion, besides wiping the blade dry after using. People have mentioned for example wiping the blade periodically with oil but no one mentioned any specific product.

Thanks

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Sun Mar 05, 2017 6:21 pm
by yablanowitz
Mineral oil is food safe, so some people like to use it on their blades. I live in a pretty dry climate, so I generally don't use anything on mine. Really rust prone steels like 1095 and O-1 may get a dab of Chap Stick smeared on the blade once in a while, if I happen to have some in my pocket, but that doesn't happen very often.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Sun Mar 05, 2017 6:46 pm
by bryan123
yablanowitz wrote:Mineral oil is food safe, so some people like to use it on their blades. I live in a pretty dry climate, so I generally don't use anything on mine. Really rust prone steels like 1095 and O-1 may get a dab of Chap Stick smeared on the blade once in a while, if I happen to have some in my pocket, but that doesn't happen very often.
Chap stick....applied with tissue or a napkin or something else?

Thanks

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Sun Mar 05, 2017 10:51 pm
by yablanowitz
Usually applied with my fingers. Touch the stick to each side of the blade, wipe with finger and thumb to spread the stuff over the whole surface, call it a day. I personally think people worry entirely too much about germs. There is a whole world out there that has not been sanitized for your protection, and I live in it. I don't sterilize my knife in an autoclave before I cut up an apple to eat either. Call me a barbarian, I don't care.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 11:22 am
by bryan123
yablanowitz wrote:Usually applied with my fingers. Touch the stick to each side of the blade, wipe with finger and thumb to spread the stuff over the whole surface, call it a day. I personally think people worry entirely too much about germs. There is a whole world out there that has not been sanitized for your protection, and I live in it. I don't sterilize my knife in an autoclave before I cut up an apple to eat either. Call me a barbarian, I don't care.
Not calling you a barbarian at all, since I'm not a germophobe either. I'm a physician specializing in immune deficiencies, but let that go. just wanted to know the preferred way to apply chapstick to my D2 blade without compromising the blade, and thanks for the info.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 12:27 pm
by SpyderEdgeForever
I am glad you mentioned this because D2 steel is interesting to me but I have been a little apprehensive about it because it is not as satiny stainless as some other knife steel, and I don't like the color shade of it much. But I have seen some good knives made from it, as well.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 8:05 pm
by yablanowitz
bryan123 wrote:
yablanowitz wrote:Usually applied with my fingers. Touch the stick to each side of the blade, wipe with finger and thumb to spread the stuff over the whole surface, call it a day. I personally think people worry entirely too much about germs. There is a whole world out there that has not been sanitized for your protection, and I live in it. I don't sterilize my knife in an autoclave before I cut up an apple to eat either. Call me a barbarian, I don't care.
Not calling you a barbarian at all, since I'm not a germophobe either. I'm a physician specializing in immune deficiencies, but let that go. just wanted to know the preferred way to apply chapstick to my D2 blade without compromising the blade, and thanks for the info.
Sorry, I get a lot of "Ewww. That's gross!" responses to some of the things I do all the time. I suppose you could apply it with a napkin or tissue or handkerchief or shirt tail or whatever else you have handy. I just always have fingers handy, that's all. Vaseline or other brand of petroleum jelly would work as well. Chap Stick is easier to carry around, and since it's safe enough to use on my lips, I figure it won't poison me if I get some on my apple. D2 is actually pretty darn close to stainless, so if you wipe it dry after use you should be good.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 9:09 pm
by SpyderNut
yablanowitz wrote:
bryan123 wrote:
yablanowitz wrote:Usually applied with my fingers. Touch the stick to each side of the blade, wipe with finger and thumb to spread the stuff over the whole surface, call it a day. I personally think people worry entirely too much about germs. There is a whole world out there that has not been sanitized for your protection, and I live in it. I don't sterilize my knife in an autoclave before I cut up an apple to eat either. Call me a barbarian, I don't care.
Not calling you a barbarian at all, since I'm not a germophobe either. I'm a physician specializing in immune deficiencies, but let that go. just wanted to know the preferred way to apply chapstick to my D2 blade without compromising the blade, and thanks for the info.
Sorry, I get a lot of "Ewww. That's gross!" responses to some of the things I do all the time. I suppose you could apply it with a napkin or tissue or handkerchief or shirt tail or whatever else you have handy. I just always have fingers handy, that's all. Vaseline or other brand of petroleum jelly would work as well. Chap Stick is easier to carry around, and since it's safe enough to use on my lips, I figure it won't poison me if I get some on my apple. D2 is actually pretty darn close to stainless, so if you wipe it dry after use you should be good.
FWIW, my dad used to "sterilize" the blade of his trusty Swiss Army knife by wiping it on his jeans prior to cutting up fruit for the kids. Seems like it must have worked as I am still alive and fairly normal. ;)

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 9:13 pm
by phillipsted
My main issue with applying a wax-based protectant to the blade would be buildup. Wax has a nasty habit of collecting bits of dust and dirt and creating a waxy residue that can gum up the innards of your knife. It sounds like you use just a very light swipe - and that's probably OK - but you'll want to occasionally clean and oil the pivot area to ensure that none of the wax has migrated there.

Personally, I use a light machine oil, mineral oil, or specialized product (such as Tuf Glide). With D2 and other "near stainless" steels, all you need is a little swipe every now and again. And if you carry it in a sweaty pocket during the summer, wipe it down after you carry. No biggie.

TedP

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 9:32 pm
by yablanowitz
The frequency with which I apply such protectants pretty much precludes the possibility of buildup. Third blue moons just don't happen that often.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 10:21 pm
by bryan123
OP here. I decided to use a very very small (pass the magnifying glass) amount of Vaseline applied with a Q-tip. I'm kind of accident prone (klutz) and I figured this was the safest way.

Thanks.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Mon Mar 06, 2017 10:28 pm
by noseoil
D2 gets a bad rap in general. It's very good steel when used properly. Not nearly as rust-prone as simple carbon steel, so a bit of care is all you need.

I typically use wd 40 for my stuff like this. Cheap & easy, but there's nothing like a bit of prevention after using a blade (rinse or clean with soapy water, dry it off) then coat lightly with wd 40 & forget about it. Living in the desert helps also....

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Tue Mar 07, 2017 6:23 am
by bryan123
noseoil wrote:D2 gets a bad rap in general. It's very good steel when used properly. Not nearly as rust-prone as simple carbon steel, so a bit of care is all you need.

I typically use wd 40 for my stuff like this. Cheap & easy, but there's nothing like a bit of prevention after using a blade (rinse or clean with soapy water, dry it off) then coat lightly with wd 40 & forget about it. Living in the desert helps also....
Would WD 40 be safe if the knife is going to be used for food prep? There's a warning to call poison control if swallowed

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Tue Mar 07, 2017 8:18 am
by noseoil
No for food prep. Yes for common sense here. Mineral oil for food prep, as was already mentioned. A "work knife" which is used in the shop or outdoors doesn't get used for food prep with our use. A food prep knife isn't used for chopping outdoors.

The D2 food knife in the trailer is just washed & dried, so far no issues with it.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Tue Mar 07, 2017 10:13 am
by Doc Dan
Vaseline. Food safe. Does not come off easy.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Tue Mar 07, 2017 10:13 am
by Doc Dan
only the lightest coat needed.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Tue Mar 07, 2017 11:17 am
by bearfacedkiller
I have quite a few knives in D2 and have never needed to do anything more than keep them clean.

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Tue Mar 07, 2017 9:50 pm
by Dr. Snubnose
bearfacedkiller wrote:I have quite a few knives in D2 and have never needed to do anything more than keep them clean.
Ditto!...Doc:)

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Tue Mar 07, 2017 11:06 pm
by Doc Dan
Me, too. However, I do not know what his climate is like. Here, I will put a bit of Vaseline as it is salty and 100% humidity all the time. Back home, I never did anything (except wash the deer blood off).

Re: D2 steel question

Posted: Wed Mar 08, 2017 10:18 pm
by awa54
bryan123 wrote: ...just wanted to know the preferred way to apply chapstick to my D2 blade without compromising the blade, and thanks for the info.

lol, I'd worry more about compromising your finger!

Don't forget the tang of the blade under the handle scales, which is hard to get to ...cleaning/lubing that area will require disassembly to do without making a mess with excess lube.

If you want a non toxic WD40 alternative there's always Ballistol :P