Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

Discuss Spyderco's products and history.
GarageBoy
Member
Posts: 2215
Joined: Sun Nov 14, 2004 6:49 pm
Location: Brooklyn NY

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#21

Post by GarageBoy »

Would vanax, lc200, etc be less brittle than white/blue at the same hardness? (More carbides means more brittleness?)
User avatar
Cambertree
Member
Posts: 1640
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2014 6:48 am
Location: Victoria, Australia

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#22

Post by Cambertree »

Enactive wrote:
Fri Oct 16, 2020 6:57 pm
Cambertree droppin knowledge in this thread like... BOOM. Thanks for sharing, bro! :cool:
Ha ha, thanks bro. :) I guess even slow learners like myself acquire a little knowledge when they have good teachers. :D :p

Here’s a couple of interesting vids on the quarrying and shaping and dressing of natural Japanese waterstones.

https://youtu.be/6ANd68k1L8o

https://youtu.be/CT4_ltOu76Y
User avatar
Cambertree
Member
Posts: 1640
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2014 6:48 am
Location: Victoria, Australia

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#23

Post by Cambertree »

GarageBoy wrote:
Fri Oct 16, 2020 8:19 pm
Would vanax, lc200, etc be less brittle than white/blue at the same hardness? (More carbides means more brittleness?)
Can’t speak to Vanax, as I haven’t tried it, but from what I understand from Larrin and Chad/Xplorer, LC200N is challenging to get harder than around 59 HRC in production knives. Maximum attainable hardness might be around 61 HRC?

So the White and Blue steels are still going to be plenty tough in that hardness range, assuming a decent heat treat.

Of course they’re usually run harder than that in most laminated kitchen knives.
User avatar
sal
Member
Posts: 16968
Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 12:00 pm
Location: Golden, Colorado USA

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#24

Post by sal »

new tack,

the steels like 52100, blue, white are capable of achieving a "sticky" edge or what Bill Bagwell always called a "hungry" edge. It does take some effort, experience and skill to achieve that level of sharpness, but these are the steels that can handle that (as Cliff Stamp calls) .1 micron.

sal
User avatar
Deadboxhero
Member
Posts: 2146
Joined: Tue Mar 01, 2016 4:35 am
Contact:

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#25

Post by Deadboxhero »

What the high carbon simple steels lack in toughness and wear they make up for it in edge stability.



From a Heat treatment point of view these kinds of steels are like a manual transmission vs a automatic, things require more set up to avoid less desirable features and to chase desired structures in the microstructure if stability is most important.

Very enjoyable to geekout on geometry, heat treatment and sharpening with.

Big Brown Bear
https://www.youtube.com/user/shawnhouston
Triple B Handmade Knives
User avatar
Cambertree
Member
Posts: 1640
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2014 6:48 am
Location: Victoria, Australia

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#26

Post by Cambertree »

Deadboxhero wrote:
Sat Oct 17, 2020 12:44 am
What the high carbon simple steels lack in toughness and wear they make up for it in edge stability.



From a Heat treatment point of view these kinds of steels are like a manual transmission vs a automatic, things require more set up to avoid less desirable features and to chase desired structures in the microstructure if stability is most important.

Very enjoyable to geekout on geometry, heat treatment and sharpening with.

Very cool, Shawn. :cool:

So what were you running that 26C3 knife at? HRC, edge angle and BTE?

I’ve seen you using 0.006” BTE thickness and 15dps with high carbide steels, but I’m wondering if you go more acute with these steels?

Do you use any cold treatment on these at all?
User avatar
Deadboxhero
Member
Posts: 2146
Joined: Tue Mar 01, 2016 4:35 am
Contact:

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#27

Post by Deadboxhero »

Cryogenic Treatment with liquid nitrogen is standard practice for me, so everything gets LN.


The 26c3 in the video was 0.010" bte with a ~15dps convex freehand edge at 65rc on 0.078" stock.


Can carbon go more acute? Difficult to say, I think the question is more accurate to ask "can the user handle more acute blades and edges?"
Cambertree wrote:
Sat Oct 17, 2020 6:41 am
Deadboxhero wrote:
Sat Oct 17, 2020 12:44 am
What the high carbon simple steels lack in toughness and wear they make up for it in edge stability.



From a Heat treatment point of view these kinds of steels are like a manual transmission vs a automatic, things require more set up to avoid less desirable features and to chase desired structures in the microstructure if stability is most important.

Very enjoyable to geekout on geometry, heat treatment and sharpening with.

Very cool, Shawn. :cool:

So what were you running that 26C3 knife at? HRC, edge angle and BTE?

I’ve seen you using 0.006” BTE thickness and 15dps with high carbide steels, but I’m wondering if you go more acute with these steels?

Do you use any cold treatment on these at all?
Big Brown Bear
https://www.youtube.com/user/shawnhouston
Triple B Handmade Knives
GarageBoy
Member
Posts: 2215
Joined: Sun Nov 14, 2004 6:49 pm
Location: Brooklyn NY

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#28

Post by GarageBoy »

I guess I should get a white/blue steel gyuto to play with? Prices vary so much. I guess I should get maybe the chosera 400/atoshi 2k?
Lucabrasi
Member
Posts: 107
Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2019 2:00 pm

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#29

Post by Lucabrasi »

This has all been said but I’ll try to contribute. Kitchen knives are what got me into knives. After running through dozens of gyutos what I have come to find is carbon steels are just what the best makers use in that world. Some great smiths work with SLD (Japanese D2), some do SG2/R2, ZDP or Hap40, the latter 2 being pretty rare. But for the most part, the most sought after smiths work in White (shirogami) 1 or 2, Blue (aogami) 1 or 2, and to a lesser extent blue super. I don’t know if it’s an unwillingness to learn to grind and heat treat higher alloyed steels or an understanding that their craft is mastering what has been passed down for generations, but the Shigefusas, Katos, Toyamas, Shirakis of the world tend to only work in white or blue steel.

As a user, they strop back to incredible levels of sharpness with ease, far exceeding the possibilities you tend to find in pm steels. They take an incredible edge to begin with and do it at incredibly thin angles, that tend to push the hardness side making the edges stable cutting on a high quality board. Nothing will cut like a white 1 blade hardened high with an edge polished on a high grit Japanese natural. At least for a while.

But yeah, they are all about precision. Bones, frozen food, just shouldn’t cut them with something high end. Keep a 30 dollar victorinox for that.
Current Spyderco: Native 5 LW s35vn; Delica zdp; Caly 3.5 zdp/CF; Chapparel FRN cts xhp; Southard 204p; Kapara s30v; Ikuchi s30v; Spydiechef lc200n, Waterway Lc200n; Manix 2 LW 20cv

Past Spyderco: Endura zdp; Manix 2 LW s110v; Paramilitary 2 s30v
Granoo Fink
Member
Posts: 151
Joined: Tue Jan 28, 2020 1:54 pm
Location: Southern Germany

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#30

Post by Granoo Fink »

Lucabrasi wrote:
Sat Oct 17, 2020 8:31 pm
This has all been said but I’ll try to contribute. Kitchen knives are what got me into knives. After running through dozens of gyutos what I have come to find is carbon steels are just what the best makers use in that world. Some great smiths work with SLD (Japanese D2), some do SG2/R2, ZDP or Hap40, the latter 2 being pretty rare. But for the most part, the most sought after smiths work in White (shirogami) 1 or 2, Blue (aogami) 1 or 2, and to a lesser extent blue super. I don’t know if it’s an unwillingness to learn to grind and heat treat higher alloyed steels or an understanding that their craft is mastering what has been passed down for generations, but the Shigefusas, Katos, Toyamas, Shirakis of the world tend to only work in white or blue steel.

As a user, they strop back to incredible levels of sharpness with ease, far exceeding the possibilities you tend to find in pm steels. They take an incredible edge to begin with and do it at incredibly thin angles, that tend to push the hardness side making the edges stable cutting on a high quality board. Nothing will cut like a white 1 blade hardened high with an edge polished on a high grit Japanese natural. At least for a while.

But yeah, they are all about precision. Bones, frozen food, just shouldn’t cut them with something high end. Keep a 30 dollar victorinox for that.
This.

And yes, a Yanagiba by Kenichi Shiraki and a good Suita are still on my wishlist for years now...
Granoo Fink
Member
Posts: 151
Joined: Tue Jan 28, 2020 1:54 pm
Location: Southern Germany

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#31

Post by Granoo Fink »

To japanese natural grindstones: most of the famous mines in the Kyoto area are depleted. Nevertheless, these mines still stock large, unprocessed rocks, some of which are quarried more than one hundred years ago, waiting to be processed into finishing stones.
As I understand, the unique properties of these grindstones made of sedimentary rock of the Kyoto area provided at least one part of the basis for the evolution of Japanese edged tools and the cutting techniques arising, wood working and food preparation.
Lucabrasi
Member
Posts: 107
Joined: Sun Nov 24, 2019 2:00 pm

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#32

Post by Lucabrasi »

I’ve found a natural edge keeps its scary sharp level a bit longer than off synthetics. Don’t have an explanation, just my observation. They also shave better for straight razors. There’s a quality to them that is hard to capture in text.

I have a pretty hard stone, a yaginoshima asagi, that can positively impact the performance of zdp and cts xhp, but once you get to steels with more vanadium, they really do nothing.

As for the simple carbons, I think most here would be surprised by the kind of edge retention you get with them in the kitchen. My Watanabe blue 2, reportedly hardened to around 65 hrc, seems to keeps its fine edge as long as my Kurosaki R2. I just never let my gyutos get to a working edge so I can’t really comment further.

I’ve been surprised how often I’ve had to sharpen my high end pm steels in pocket knives to keep the scary edge on them. But yes, once the edge settles into just usable sharpness they do last a very long time.
Current Spyderco: Native 5 LW s35vn; Delica zdp; Caly 3.5 zdp/CF; Chapparel FRN cts xhp; Southard 204p; Kapara s30v; Ikuchi s30v; Spydiechef lc200n, Waterway Lc200n; Manix 2 LW 20cv

Past Spyderco: Endura zdp; Manix 2 LW s110v; Paramilitary 2 s30v
User avatar
Abyss_Fish
Member
Posts: 811
Joined: Tue Apr 21, 2020 3:23 pm
Location: Minnesota, USA.

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#33

Post by Abyss_Fish »

SG2/R2 is glorious. Preforms like xhp run super hard, and yet even though it’s usually at 62-64 hrc it still rarely chips. Wonderful wonderful wonderful.

Edit: although to answer your initial question, I think it’s a tradition thing. One of my chefs swears by a few 40-60 year old french chefs knives. He doesn’t know what the steel is (I’d guess 52100) and doesn’t really care. It’s run hard, it’s easy to maintain, and as long as one of the line cooks doesn’t leave it in a sink, it’s indestructible. It’s a “they don’t make em like this anymore” thing, without a doubt.
Lightly insane.

Current spydie collection: Watu, Rhino, UKPK Salt G10 bladeswap, Yojimbo 2 Smooth G10 Cru-Wear, Manix lw “mystic” 20cv, SmallFly 2, Waterway, Ladybug k390, Caribbean
Current favorite steels: sg2/R2, lc200n/Z-FiNit, 3v
User avatar
Cambertree
Member
Posts: 1640
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2014 6:48 am
Location: Victoria, Australia

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#34

Post by Cambertree »

Deadboxhero wrote:
Sat Oct 17, 2020 12:53 pm
Cryogenic Treatment with liquid nitrogen is standard practice for me, so everything gets LN.


The 26c3 in the video was 0.010" bte with a ~15dps convex freehand edge at 65rc on 0.078" stock.


Can carbon go more acute? Difficult to say, I think the question is more accurate to ask "can the user handle more acute blades and edges?"
Thanks Shawn, you’re doing some very impressive work. :cool:

Yeah, I think you’re right - it’s easy enough for the user to modify the edge grind and angle, as long as the primary flats are ground nice and thin like yours are. :cool:
SharpFrank
Member
Posts: 7
Joined: Thu Oct 29, 2020 7:20 am

Re: Kitchen knife nerds- why basic carbons?

#35

Post by SharpFrank »

qwkzotc wrote:
Thu Oct 15, 2020 2:29 pm
All of my Japanese slicers (razers) are SG2/R2. Anything that gets near a bone such as a Honesuki is a good blue/white carbon. I also have a full rack of Traditional/Spyderco kitchen knives and a 1 1/2lb full tang carbon Cleaver. Just like EDC, I think it is good to have a full range of steels, sizes and shapes available to choose from when you are ready to use them.

Hi. I envy you. I only have two cleavers to choose from
Post Reply