Delica 4 or Manix 2?

[ZesT]

I like to do a lot of back packing and also want an EDC that I am not afraid to abuse. So the question is, Orange Delica 4 FFG or Lightweight FRCP Manix 2?

[Sully]

Can't go wrong with either, obviously. Manix 2 if you're really liking the CBBL on your XL, I'd say. Lightweight for serious backpacking and can handle even tougher jobs. Love that Delica 4 too, such a great value. Still....mentioning "backpacking" makes me think LW Manix 2.

[rmeron]

I don't backpack but I carry a grey Delica 4 in the bottom of my pocket and either a Manix 2 LW or Endura clipped to the top.
Overkill maybe, but I'm happy.

[harronek]

I like to do a lot of back backing ?

That sounds like something that should only be done by two consenting adults :)

I vote for the Delica , it's my favourite knife .

Ken

[Holzfaeller]

I prefer the more robust blade and the grip of the Manix 2 LW over the Delica. The Delica doesn't fill my hand like the Manix.

[tangent]

I say Delica...but I would go with the saber grind. Although I love the FFG, I feel the saber grind is really better for all around use. Much stronger tip and still slices well. I love the orange handle too...that is why I put a saber ground blade in an orange handle. Basically, I went the extra mile.

[abbazaba]

I prefer the more robust blade and the grip of the Manix 2 LW over the Delica. The Delica doesn't fill my hand like the Manix.

+1

[bdblue]

I have done a lot of backpacking (before I was a serious knife enthusiast) and I carried a knife the general size and weight of the Delica. I recall that I did very little cutting with the knife. These days the Manix 2 is one of my favorite sizes for a user knife so that is what I would choose. But for backpacking use I think the 2 knives would work about equally as well so pick the one that you like best.

[Evil D]

I would always choose the Manix over a Delica, but for backpacking/hiking it may be better to go with the Delica since it's a brighter color.

[Brock O Lee]

I would go with the Manix LW, with a bright colour lanyard :p

[SG89]

Manix 2 LW S110V if you like CBBL. Delica 4 VG10 in orange for visibility. What about an Endura 4?

[ZesT]

I never really felt love for the endura....

[zhyla]

Manix 2 no doubt. But unless a few ounces is going to make a big difference I would go with the G10 Manix 2. It's just sturdier. Especially if you end up putting a lot of lateral torque on the blade.

[Doc Dan]

Back packing? Endura or a Native 5.

[Johnnie1801]

I have both and for backpacking I'd choose the LW Manix over the Delica.The Manix is bigger, has a comfortable grip and only weighs 14 grams more than the Delica (Delica 66g Vs. Manix 80g).

Couple of comparison pic's

[mjbruiser]

[quote="Johnnie1801"]I have both and for backpacking I'd choose the LW Manix over the Delica.The Manix is bigger, has a comfortable grip and only weighs 14 grams more than the Delica (Delica 66g Vs. Manix 80g).

Couple of comparison pic's

Great pics! Do you have any of the Manix 2 and the Endura 4 side-by-side?

[ejames13]

I would choose the Delica, not necessarily because I think it's better for backpacking, but just because I like the design better than the Manix. I've only been backpacking a handful of times, but I don't recall ever needing a knife for more than opening a package or cutting some rope. I always brought a small hatchet and machete for heavier duty tasks.

FWIW, I feel like Stretch vs Manix would be a better comparison. And in that scenario I would choose the Stretch.

[zhyla]

Manix 2 G-10, no question in my mind at all. It's sturdier and easier to grip with cold fingers or gloves. The extra couple ounces may offend the ultralite types but it's worth it.

[ShaneInDenver]

Great pics! Do you have any of the Manix 2 and the Endura 4 side-by-side?

Of the options presented I would go with the Manix 2 in whatever steel you feel comfortable keeping sharp. I backpack 4-5 trips a year and I usually carry a PM2 and an Esee Izula.

Here is the Manix 2 and the Endure 4 side by side: