Where do the best made Spydies come from?
- araneae
- Member
- Posts: 5494
- Joined: Wed Aug 09, 2006 10:10 pm
- Location: A lil more south of the Erie shore, Ohio
Where do the best made Spydies come from?
Another thread has given me the idea of making this poll. I want to know where you think the best Spydies are coming from right now. I mean manufacturing/quality/fit and finish. This could be an interesting report card for Spyderco.
Golden, CO
Seki Japan
Taichung Taiwan
China
Italy
Golden, CO
Seki Japan
Taichung Taiwan
China
Italy
So many knives, so few pockets... :)
-Nick
Last in: N5 Magnacut
The "Spirit" of the design does not come through unless used. -Sal
-Nick
Last in: N5 Magnacut
The "Spirit" of the design does not come through unless used. -Sal
-
- Member
- Posts: 3660
- Joined: Tue Jan 18, 2011 7:30 pm
- Location: Toronto Canada
- I_like_sharp_things
- Member
- Posts: 253
- Joined: Tue Apr 19, 2011 3:37 pm
- Location: America
I think nobody can make perfect product, at least not yet.
From my experience I would put Italy on the first place. I had five knives made in Italy, all of the flawless. But five pieces probably is not sufficient sample to make a judgement. I had five knives made in Taichung. Fit and Finish is excellent, but my Navaja has such a thick grind, that cutting is not fun at all, I would rather had cosmetic flaw. My C95 is a better slicer today. Hopefully Tom Krein will improve it. I owned about 20 knives from Golden, only one of them had minor blemish on scale. Over 80 of my :spyder: were made in Japan: Superhawk was missing some steel on the spine, two of Kopas had some cosmetic issues. Everything was resolve by Spyderco CS. I would say that today I satisfied with Golden and Italian made :spyder: the best.
I beleive that all plants have some room for improvement. Also I still didn't find the brand, which fits my taste and needs better than Spyderco.
From my experience I would put Italy on the first place. I had five knives made in Italy, all of the flawless. But five pieces probably is not sufficient sample to make a judgement. I had five knives made in Taichung. Fit and Finish is excellent, but my Navaja has such a thick grind, that cutting is not fun at all, I would rather had cosmetic flaw. My C95 is a better slicer today. Hopefully Tom Krein will improve it. I owned about 20 knives from Golden, only one of them had minor blemish on scale. Over 80 of my :spyder: were made in Japan: Superhawk was missing some steel on the spine, two of Kopas had some cosmetic issues. Everything was resolve by Spyderco CS. I would say that today I satisfied with Golden and Italian made :spyder: the best.
I beleive that all plants have some room for improvement. Also I still didn't find the brand, which fits my taste and needs better than Spyderco.
"People sleep peaceably in their beds at night only because rough men stand ready to do violence on their behalf"
My top choices Natives5, Calys, C83 Persian
My top choices Natives5, Calys, C83 Persian
- Fred Sanford
- Member
- Posts: 5734
- Joined: Fri Jun 02, 2006 12:41 pm
- Location: Ohio, USA
-
- Member
- Posts: 47
- Joined: Tue Dec 28, 2010 1:33 pm
- Location: The bonnie banks o' Loch Lomond
1. Taiwan
2. Golden
3. Seki
2. Golden
3. Seki
Spydies owned: Sage, Sage 2, Sage 3, Sage 4, Lum CF, Lum (foliage), Para Military, Gayle Bradley, Caly 3, M390 Military, Military (orange), PM 2 (orange), Dodo (orange), Manix 2 (orange), Manix 2 (moonglow), Merlin, Matriarch SE, UKPK (maroon), Chinook 3, Khukuri, Superhawk, Street Beat, Lum Tanto sprint, Massad Ayoob sprint, PPT, Shabaria, Persian (red), JD Smith (foliage), BayouShooter Endura, and P'kal.
Waiting for: Dark green PM2.
Waiting for: Dark green PM2.
- jabba359
- Member
- Posts: 4958
- Joined: Fri Feb 10, 2006 11:07 pm
- Location: North Hollywood, CA U.S.A. Earth
- Contact:
I voted Taiwan. They are putting out some excellent work, even considering the grit problems they've had with the Chaparral. Second is Japan, and while I've had the most problems with them, this may be colored by the fact that I have more Japan models than all the rest put together, so I've had more opportunity to run into problems. My Caly3 came a bit gritty (cleaned out easily) and I have cosmetic blemishes on my Khukuri and Superhawk, but I just threw them in my pocket, put them to work, and don't even notice the flaws now that they have usage marks on them now anyway. These small things aside, the Japan knives seem to be well finished and the imperfections I've gotten are minor. I would put Golden third, but don't have a large sampling of their models so I may not have the best insight into them. But what I have noticed is that they tend to have the least polish and, while functionally are fine, are a little bit rougher. Last would be China, but only because they use lower quality steels and such. For the price, they are fantastic! I can't really rank Italy has I only have one from there (it's excellent). So, in summation:
1) Taiwan
2) Japan
3) Golden
4) China
1) Taiwan
2) Japan
3) Golden
4) China
- The Deacon
- Member
- Posts: 25717
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:33 am
- Location: Upstate SC, USA
- Contact:
Hard one to vote on. For one thing, by specifying Seki it effectively left out Japan's best maker, Moki. More importantly for me, the truth is that, with the exception of China, I've owned extremely well finished Spydercos from all those places, plus Switzerland. I've also owned, or seen firsthand, mediocre ones from all of them, plus Germany.
As it is, I'd put China at the bottom of the list. I imagine that, as with every other country Spyderco knives have been produced in plus at least a couple more, there are shops there capable of consistently turning out knives with "world class" fit and finish if the company they are making them for is willing to pay for that level of workmanship. But the knife buying public is not ready to accept that yet, so having decent, if unspectacular, knives that can be sold at "low end" prices made there makes more sense.
Italy, along with Switzerland and Germany, suffer from too few examples to allow a really well informed opinion. The Volpe I had was very good, but the Hossoms I've seen were inconsistent, at best and I've yet to see a Squeak.
Currently, the maker in Taichung seems to be doing the best in terms of consistently excellent fit and finish. On the other hand, Spyderco's other maker in Taiwan has turned out some less than stellar work over the years.
Japan has both the advantage and disadvantage of quantity. Over the 30 years that makers there have been producing knives for Spyderco, they've turn out some truly spectacular ones, and some truly unspectacular ones as well. Even Moki, arguably the best maker there, has been inconsistent over time. But, after a period of truly lackluster production, they've been doing some really good work for the past couple years. G Sakai is more inconsistent, but can definitely do some great work. The CF Balance is exquisite, but some of their other CF work has been much less so. They also occasionally suffer from Golden's biggest F&F shortcoming on full liner knives, A roughness I'd describe as chatter on the exposed perimeter.
Which brings us to Golden. IMHO, their forte is hard use knives and, perhaps because of that and Sal's "tractors don't need to look like Ferraris" , they often place less emphasis on the esthetic than I'd like. That said, the F&F of the one ti Military I've seen close up was as good as that on any Spyderco I own.
As it is, I'd put China at the bottom of the list. I imagine that, as with every other country Spyderco knives have been produced in plus at least a couple more, there are shops there capable of consistently turning out knives with "world class" fit and finish if the company they are making them for is willing to pay for that level of workmanship. But the knife buying public is not ready to accept that yet, so having decent, if unspectacular, knives that can be sold at "low end" prices made there makes more sense.
Italy, along with Switzerland and Germany, suffer from too few examples to allow a really well informed opinion. The Volpe I had was very good, but the Hossoms I've seen were inconsistent, at best and I've yet to see a Squeak.
Currently, the maker in Taichung seems to be doing the best in terms of consistently excellent fit and finish. On the other hand, Spyderco's other maker in Taiwan has turned out some less than stellar work over the years.
Japan has both the advantage and disadvantage of quantity. Over the 30 years that makers there have been producing knives for Spyderco, they've turn out some truly spectacular ones, and some truly unspectacular ones as well. Even Moki, arguably the best maker there, has been inconsistent over time. But, after a period of truly lackluster production, they've been doing some really good work for the past couple years. G Sakai is more inconsistent, but can definitely do some great work. The CF Balance is exquisite, but some of their other CF work has been much less so. They also occasionally suffer from Golden's biggest F&F shortcoming on full liner knives, A roughness I'd describe as chatter on the exposed perimeter.
Which brings us to Golden. IMHO, their forte is hard use knives and, perhaps because of that and Sal's "tractors don't need to look like Ferraris" , they often place less emphasis on the esthetic than I'd like. That said, the F&F of the one ti Military I've seen close up was as good as that on any Spyderco I own.
Paul
My Personal Website ---- Beginners Guide to Spyderco Collecting ---- Spydiewiki
Deplorable :p
WTC # 1458 - 1504 - 1508 - Never Forget, Never Forgive!
My Personal Website ---- Beginners Guide to Spyderco Collecting ---- Spydiewiki
Deplorable :p
WTC # 1458 - 1504 - 1508 - Never Forget, Never Forgive!
- dalefuller
- Member
- Posts: 469
- Joined: Sat Feb 26, 2005 1:37 pm
- Location: Atlanta
I've never had a Spyderco from China or Italy, but all the other countries do a fine job on the models that I've had from their factories. I don't have a favorite "country of origin" for my Spydercos. I've been satisfied with the quality of the models that I buy from whichever country makes them.
I have a fondness for VG10 lockbacks and Japan does them very well. I really like my Paras (I have 5 of them) and the USA (at least the Golden part of it) is as good as anyone at making quality knives. The sages I used to have were perfect in every way as far as their manufacturing quality.
Really... I feel strongly each way.
I have a fondness for VG10 lockbacks and Japan does them very well. I really like my Paras (I have 5 of them) and the USA (at least the Golden part of it) is as good as anyone at making quality knives. The sages I used to have were perfect in every way as far as their manufacturing quality.
Really... I feel strongly each way.
Regards,
Dale
"If there are no dogs in Heaven, then when I die I want to go where they went."
~ Will Rogers, 1879-1935
Dale
"If there are no dogs in Heaven, then when I die I want to go where they went."
~ Will Rogers, 1879-1935
- jackknifeh
- Member
- Posts: 8412
- Joined: Fri Jul 09, 2010 6:01 am
- Location: Florida panhandle
I voted Taiwan and am writing this before reading any posts to keep my initial opinion to this question from being influenced. The quality of the GB and Sage1, my two most recent gets is perfect. That's not saying any others are flawed, just the Taiwan knives are more recent. Now I'll read other's posts.
Jack
Jack
- phillipsted
- Member
- Posts: 3674
- Joined: Tue Oct 05, 2010 11:30 am
- Location: North Virginia
-
- Member
- Posts: 1032
- Joined: Sun Jan 09, 2005 8:45 am
- Location: The Netherlands