I was looking to buy another Spyderco knife and had the list narrowed down to these 3. Trouble is, each one has its good points to me. I was wondering what the forum's opinions are of these knives and which one is overall preferred.
This knife will largely serve as EDC, though they are all large enough that smaller knives will sometimes sub in. I like all of them, and was wondering if anyone had handled all 3 and could give me a rundown.
Thanks a lot. <img src="smile.gif" width=15 height=15 align=middle>
Keepin' it real...real sharp, that is.
Dyad vs. Chinook vs. Native
-
Sword and Shield
- Member
- Posts: 2050
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:33 am
- Location: USA
I have never handled the Dyad, so I can only speculate on it.
The Chinook vs. Native - The Native is a feather compared to the Chinook. The Native has a reversible clip (if that matters to you - it does to me because even though I am right-handed, I find the Native works wonderfully for both left and right hand use, even for a right-hander.)
The lock action on the Native is smooth as silk, and this lockback is as easy to use as a liner lock. I cannot say the same for the Chinook.
Since they are both have the same blade steel, for an EDC, I would strongly recommend the Native. Get one of the G-10 Natives if you can, but there are many that find the FRN just as satisfying.
Don't get me wrong, I like my Chinook, but these are very different animals. Plus, the Native is about 1/2 the cost of either the Chinook or Dyad.
Since I don't much like serrated edges, I am not particularly intersted in the Dyad as a carry knife.
"Chance favors the prepared mind" - Louis Pasteur
The Chinook vs. Native - The Native is a feather compared to the Chinook. The Native has a reversible clip (if that matters to you - it does to me because even though I am right-handed, I find the Native works wonderfully for both left and right hand use, even for a right-hander.)
The lock action on the Native is smooth as silk, and this lockback is as easy to use as a liner lock. I cannot say the same for the Chinook.
Since they are both have the same blade steel, for an EDC, I would strongly recommend the Native. Get one of the G-10 Natives if you can, but there are many that find the FRN just as satisfying.
Don't get me wrong, I like my Chinook, but these are very different animals. Plus, the Native is about 1/2 the cost of either the Chinook or Dyad.
Since I don't much like serrated edges, I am not particularly intersted in the Dyad as a carry knife.
"Chance favors the prepared mind" - Louis Pasteur
-
vampyrewolf
- Member
- Posts: 7486
- Joined: Fri Sep 24, 2004 10:33 am
- Location: Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada
I've had a chance to handle all 3... don't own any of them... yet...
dyad: seems like longtem use would be uncomfortable. The 2nd blade just doesn't sit right when I hold it. other than taht it seems like a nice knife.
native: very comfortable for a folder(vs a fixed blade), the grooves work for me. I found it akward to open(not enough hole above handle) though.
chinook: a folding bowie! this is one that handles and feels like a fixed blade. You know when you have it, and can hear it lock a mile away. A great addition to any EDC collection, I just need $300 for it.
We all start with 10 fingers. Those with Spydies have 9 to spare, Still need a thumb. Good thing I still have 8 to spare...
dyad: seems like longtem use would be uncomfortable. The 2nd blade just doesn't sit right when I hold it. other than taht it seems like a nice knife.
native: very comfortable for a folder(vs a fixed blade), the grooves work for me. I found it akward to open(not enough hole above handle) though.
chinook: a folding bowie! this is one that handles and feels like a fixed blade. You know when you have it, and can hear it lock a mile away. A great addition to any EDC collection, I just need $300 for it.
We all start with 10 fingers. Those with Spydies have 9 to spare, Still need a thumb. Good thing I still have 8 to spare...
I own both the Dyad and the Native. Have never handled the Chinook.
The way I have my EDC carry rotation worked out, I carry the Native the most of any of my knives. I think it is great! It is sturdily made, easy to operate, I always close it one-handed, using my leg. Has a good point, and overall good blade shape. If need be, it would be there for self defense.
I never carry my Dyad. But, that probably says more about my knife using habits than it does the knife. If I were a person who was frequently using a knife, and some of those jobs could be better done, I'd carry it a lot. It is not the most comfortable knife to carry. The serrated sheepsfoot is the primary blade -- I'd reverse that, given the chance. The serrated blade is very hefty and strong, and a bit longer than the plain edged blade. It is surprisingly delicate, with an uprising point -- brain fart, can't remember what you call that. It should be a real slicer with it's apparent flat grind. Thought not terribly stout, the PE edge should serve okay in self defense.
I have the FRN Native, with the 440V steel. I love the light weight of the knife. The Dyad, with 2 blades and micarta handles is a heavy brute. YOu really know you have something in your pocket when carrying it.
Wish I could say something about the Chinook, but cannot w/no experience.
Stare
The way I have my EDC carry rotation worked out, I carry the Native the most of any of my knives. I think it is great! It is sturdily made, easy to operate, I always close it one-handed, using my leg. Has a good point, and overall good blade shape. If need be, it would be there for self defense.
I never carry my Dyad. But, that probably says more about my knife using habits than it does the knife. If I were a person who was frequently using a knife, and some of those jobs could be better done, I'd carry it a lot. It is not the most comfortable knife to carry. The serrated sheepsfoot is the primary blade -- I'd reverse that, given the chance. The serrated blade is very hefty and strong, and a bit longer than the plain edged blade. It is surprisingly delicate, with an uprising point -- brain fart, can't remember what you call that. It should be a real slicer with it's apparent flat grind. Thought not terribly stout, the PE edge should serve okay in self defense.
I have the FRN Native, with the 440V steel. I love the light weight of the knife. The Dyad, with 2 blades and micarta handles is a heavy brute. YOu really know you have something in your pocket when carrying it.
Wish I could say something about the Chinook, but cannot w/no experience.
Stare
