Spyderco Forums

Manix 2 has already been done in M4- somebody remind me how 4V is better than M4.

1) Did you purchase a Mule Team knife in the past? yes, quite a few 2) Did you put a handle on it? I bought handles for a few and I made handles for 3 3) Did you make or buy a sheath? I made a kydex sheath 4) Did you test the performance of your Mule? no 5) Did you test the performance against other...

I have multiples of each. The ergonomics are pretty much identical. The LW is much lighter, even a little bit lighter than a PM2. The G10 version is a bit heavier than the PM2. I like the G10 version as a work knife, the LW version more for EDC. I have no idea if there is a difference in strength. W...

I have almost 10 in my rotation, but some of them are just variations so I only have 2 actual models- PM2 and Manix2. I have 4 different versions of PM2 and 2 different versions of Manix 2. Add a Manix 2 XL and that makes 3 different versions. And I have one lonely knife from another brand. I have a...

I've been there too, in my knife hobby, my watch hobby, and others. I waited and watched for a long time and finally found many of the item(s) I was looking for. A few eluded me but as time passed my tastes changed and I ended up looking for other things. I learned that even though I yearned for som...

But the longer a folder gets (PM2 vs Para 3...), the further away your hand is from the opening hole when drawing from a tip UP position. So that can be an argument for tip down on the longer of two folders. From what I've read over the years from Sal and others who prefer tip down, it comes down t...

Assuming right front pocket carry, there are advantages and disadvantages to both positions. Assuming carry in other pockets that may dictate position. When knives first started having clips, they were almost universally tip down. When Spyderco started molding FRN handles those knives ended up tip u...

Liner lock and compression lock don't have an affect on how easy it is for a knife to open, there is a little detent built into the blade independent of the lock type that keeps it closed. This little detent can wear and make the blade easier to open but I can't tell that any of mine have worn or ch...

We've tried this poll in the past and it is impossible to get much consensus on a model. Let Sal choose and we will always get something interesting.

Very exciting- I'm in!

Not a simple question and an online forum almost certainly will not give you a complete understanding of the topic, but a simple example of axial loading of a steel rod can help explain some of these concepts. Some terminology: Stress: force normalized by the cross-sectional area over which the for...

For me it is 7- 4 variations of the PM2 and 3 variations of the Manix 2-

PM2 in CF/M4, Jade/satin M4, Jade/DLC M4, Blurple S110V
M2 LW S110V, M2 LW (orange) S90V, M2 XL S30V

My favorite size would have a 3.5" blade but I do carry knives up to 4" blades. My favorite knives are the in the range of the PM2, Manix 2 LW and Manix 2 G10 so this tells you my size and weight preferences. I like the Military and Manix 2 XL, but I've tried knives a bit heavier and found that it w...

I don't like or dislike the PM3, I've never even seen one in person, but it is too small for me. The PM2 is barely large enough and I like it a lot. As for "against the grain", I dislike lockback knives and I dislike tip up knives. But I do own some of each so it's not a complete deal breaker for me.

Over the past 7 days I carried M4 and D2. Of the knives that I normally carry and use- (11 Spyderco and 1 BM) I have 5 in M4, 2 in S110V, 1 in S90V, 1 in S30V, 2 in Cruwear and 1 in D2. I have one more in M4 and one more in 154CM that get used occasionally, and a couple of old ones in ATS34 that I m...

rangefinder wrote: ↑

Wed Nov 06, 2019 12:38 pm

Here's an old picture of Sal demonstrating the Sharpmaker. This is 1981, so it's pretty early.

I still have the one, an older version than that one, that I bought from him at the Texas State Fair. Mine has the wooden base, round sticks, and typewritten instructions.

For me it's an old franken-Manix 2 with M4 blade and black G10 scales. I bought it that way and don't know the story behind it. It has a lot of honest patina like an old tool and I treat it like a pure tool and use it as a weekend work knife around the house.

I don't pry with knives unless absolutely necessary. Years ago I worked in my father's garage, and carried a traditional folder that he had handed down to me. The main blade had the tip snapped off so I ground it nice and square and used it as a pocket screwdriver. It could also cut wire, belts and ...

In reality it is probably my Manix 2 Cruwear, but I treat my Manix 2 M4 as if it is a tough knife.

M4 is my favorite Spyderco steel, I have 5 of them for various uses. IMO a replacement for M4 should have similar edge-holding but better toughness. Otherwise why bother.